Stella's Ice Cream - Caldwell - Caldwell, Idaho

Blake Stish

Awesome experience! Friendly staff eager to help and to tell us about all the flavors and options!

Went with the brownie Sunday with a scoop of cookie monster and mint brownie! Both exceptional choices! Delivered great flavor with a consistent mixture of added goodies!

Daughter had a waffle cone with a scoop of chocolate and was over the moon with the taste!
Wasn't much left to picture but it was excellent!

Thank you for the great experience and new place to go to when we need a sweet treat!

Julie Hapiuk

Cute, cozy place to sit and cool off with a tasty treat. Seasonal and regular flavors will keep you coming back. Many fun choices of cones, too. The kids and adults loved it. Great, friendly service. Besides by the scoop, they will hand pack pints to take home too. They also have dairy-free and gluten-free ice cream. There is a drive-thru if you don't have time to come inside. I am glad I finally went inside after driving by so many times. I will definitely be back.

Bird Fleck

Employees were super nice. Ice cream is amazing! They have pints to go, ice cream cakes, cool looking push up pops, and cookies! They have games you can play in a comfy seating area! They switch out their flavors and have a lot of fun flavors! They make their own waffle cones and bowls. The place smells amazing!

One thing I would change is to fix the air conditioning. I know the ice cream should cool us off, but wow it's hot inside!

Flower Power was amazing! Lavender blueberry!

Fun place to go and have ice cream.

sidney thomas

Pictures of Flavors/Prices: We came in on May 15th, 2023.

We came in around 5:30 pm- Our server was AWESOME, she didn't skimp on our ice cream and was super nice!
All the tables in the lobby were wiped down, clean, and the chairs were pushed in. Behind the counter, it was also clean and tidy.
We liked the dipped cones and appreciated that she had one of each flavor in each size (not a huge stack on the counter waiting, and getting stale). It was nice having options, while not feeling limited on sizes and knowing you were getting a fresh cone. Plus we didn’t have to wait to have one made and with the chocolate already being set, helped avoid any messes
(again our server- she was awesome)

Love that this shop is family friendly-the store had clean music playing (which is unfortunately rare nowadays) and they have a stack of games, you can pick from to play. It made our experience fun and added to our night.
They had some great flavors and looking forward to coming back to try their other limited-time flavors before they are gone! (though I do wish they had a timeline for seasonal flavors so you know ~about~ how much longer you have to try them- having it on their site or social media would be especially helpful)

Cassy Poseley

We love going to Stella's. Right when u walk in it smells absolutely amazing. The kids enjoy all the yummy flavors and we all love being able to play a game together while there too.

Jessi Smith

The customer service is always very kind and quick. And usually knows what we like, unless there's a huge turnover. Which seems as though that's how it's been the last few months. Amazing ice cream.

Eileen Bennett

Yummy creamy n cold. Got the secret flavor. Loved it! Our group of 8 were served quickly and with a smile, including lots of free tasting. Our 4 yr old was super happy. Fresh & roomy, clean bright & new shop.

Jo Smith

Love the ice cream! Soooo many great options. Weve only been to the Caldwell location, we've been told to check Instagram every morning because they post that days ice cream flavors. Great customer service! My only complaint would be that they have a punch card rewards system. I don't know if it's a company thing, but most places ask if you have a rewards thing with them. IF YOU USE CASH, MAKE SURE TO ASK TO OUT IN YOUR REWARDS INFO.They don't. My friend checked out before me. They didn't ask her ( which means she got no credit for what she spent.) I checked out and mentioned, "Don't you have a rewards system?" The gal told me yes, and I put my number in. I asked if there was a way to put credit for hers after the fact. She said no, there's not. Then she tried blaming it on training the new girl and her not knowing. Expect she's the one who put my stuff in, and she didn't ask me.
Due to allergies, Stella's is the only place my friends' kids can come. I looked at my friend and she said I've been in here 4 times and they've never asked me for my phone number. Which means I've never gotten credit. Such a bummer..